Milton Academy reunion gift email fundraising ideasThis summer is my class reunion from Milton Academy. (A George Bush was president when I graduated but I won’t tell you which one.)

All reunions have class gifts. As a fundraising coach, I figured fundraising from my classmates should be a cinch.

It wasn’t! I found myself making all the mistakes I coach people not to make.

Here are some things I had to relearn:

  1. Don’t delay making the ask

    Get as early a start as possible. Most people will probably give closer to the deadline, but starting early allows you to get some early success under your belt.

  2. Batch emails in groups of 5-10

    As I tell my Fundraising Kick community, batching contacts makes the entire process much easier. It usually takes an inordinant amount of effort to do the first ask. And most stop there. But if you were planning on doing multiple asks, you’ll find the second isn’t as hard as the first. And the ninth is much easier than the second. You’ll also find yourself improving your wording and getting better at asking as you go.

  3. Don’t apologize

    My first contacts with many of my classmates was this email soliciting them for the class gift. These were so hard to write! I found myself making the classic nonprofit mistake of delaying the ask. I wanted to apologize for not communicating over the decades. To talk about the weather. To ask if they were married or not. (How awkward an opening would that have been?!)

    Rubbish! They already knew I hadn’t been in touch with them! And for that matter, I knew they hadn’t been in touch with me either. I just needed to get to the point. Why waste their time or mine?

    I simply said something like, “Hi Joe, Can you believe it’s reunion time again?! We’re starting to look like those ‘grown up’ people in the Milton magazine! Part of our reunion is raising a $35,000 class gift. They’re making it ridiculously easy to participate. Leadership giving is only $1798 and can be paid over five years. Would you join us?”

  4. Send to individuals

    I sent to individuals. That way I could add their name and any pertinent information. To me, sending a blanket email with all the addresses in the BCC, is like photocopying a form letter and sticking it in the local chamber of commerce’s newsletter. Not very effective.

  5. Send yourself a BCC

    While I don’t like to use the BCC for sending emails, I do like to put my own email address in the BCC. That way I get to see how my email looks when it goes through the email system.

Reading over these email tips, it strikes me that they apply to fundraising in general:

  • Start now
  • Batch your calls
  • Get to the point
  • Personalize contacts
  • Include yourself on your own mailing list.

Nothing earth shattering here, but I have always contended that the basics are extreme!

What tips would you add?

21 Ways for Board Members to Engage with their Nonprofit's Fundraising book image

You'll discover the 21 ways each board member can help their nonprofit's fundraising - even if they don't like to ask for money!

As a bonus, you'll get free fundraising tips every other week too!

Help your board fundraise for nonprofit with this FREE ebook

We take your privacy very seriously and will never sell, rent, or share your email address.